As Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney prepared to welcome a delegation from the European Union to Montreal on the 29th of October, he simultaneously worked behind the scenes to prepare another major investment announcement. Within the first two minutes of his address at the Canada-EU summit, a landmark meeting of the leadership apparatuses for both sides, Mr. Carney made his grand declaration: the Canadian government would be purchasing an equity stake worth $1.6 billion in Cohere, a Toronto-based artificial intelligence company. While the political appeal of announcing a major job-generating commitment after a second consecutive monthly rise in the unemployment rate is obvious, this partnership between the Government of Canada and Cohere is far more impactful than any regular expansion of the national workforce.
During his first two years as prime minister, Mr. Carney has been explicit in his leadership objectives: he does not intend to fade into the background of Canadian political history. Rather, Mr. Carney aims to be a transformative figure by putting his government at the frontier of a generational nation-building project under the Canada Strong banner—an agenda that embraces immediate action to get ahead of potential competitors in the industry. However, as artificial intelligence becomes increasingly prevalent in our daily lives, the government must make AI policy a priority to help Canada protect its data sovereignty. Mr. Carney has already proven to be a leader that is eager to confront Canada’s long-term issues with his trademark values-based realism, a political ideology based on pragmatic decision-making. In order to truly live up to the billing of the man for the future, he must outline a coherent and reasonable stance on AI. To invoke the aphorism of Lao Tzu, “the journey of a thousand miles begins with one step;” collaboration with Cohere to put Canada on the cutting edge is a necessary first step on this long road.
An (AI) Revolution. . .
Large language models, like ChatGPT, may not have reached their maximum potential yet, but the global community has already passed the phase of proto-industrialization on this frontier. Across the 135 countries currently recognized by the United Nations, 126 have developed AI policy in some capacity. The vast majority of these countries currently deploy AI in government, particularly in the areas of data analysis and forecasting. In Canada, most federal departments have fully embraced these systems, helping to automate workflow and improve efficiency in many sectors, with Mr. Carney, for his part, predicting an increase in business adoption of AI from twelve per cent to sixty per cent by 2034.
Correspondingly, there has been a powerful wave of anti-AI sentiment, especially among youth. Data centres have become a highly salient topic amidst fears of environmental strains, such as freshwater depletion. Public debate regarding AI usage in the American government, especially in Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth’s Department of War, have further tarnished its reputation. There are serious worries about the impact of generative models on culture and the arts, which must eventually be confronted as the AI ‘boom’ continues to proliferate. Regardless of this skepticism, global leaders do not seem likely to turn their attention away from the technology.
For better or worse, it appears likely that AI is going to fundamentally shape the trajectory of humankind for the next generation. Even if the current bubble pops, the general consensus among economists is that AI will follow a theoretical curve known as the Gartner Hype Cycle. The Gartner Hype Cycle suggests that new innovative technologies can often supersede a brief trough of disillusionment following the peak of expectations and eventually plateau as a productive invention. For these reasons, it is plausible to assume Mr. Carney understands that failing to embrace the AI revolution could risk limiting the strategic and economic preparedness of current and future Canadian governments.
Challenging the Tyranny of the Minority
Following a major funding increase of over $7 billion, Cohere announced aims to become a flagship AI company that is not compromised by the United States or China. It has been speculated that data giants in those two countries are on the verge of consolidating even more power as global AI usage continues to increase exponentially. If this consolidation comes to pass, tech giants like Sam Altman and Elon Musk would be able to impose undue leverage on the global community, as countries’ dependence on their respective AI providers skyrocket. Therefore, in the future, the West could potentially be dominated by oligopolies and tyranny of the AI controlling minority.
With its recent investment into Cohere, Canada can feasibly avoid the constraints of frontier fatalism, a theory that implies that Chinese and American models will monopolize the world and turn AI into a virtual renter’s market. By shifting its reliance from foreign providers, Canada can now set the rules of the game on its AI strategy. The federal government’s display of faith in Cohere could possibly lure private investors to help bolster Cohere’s capacity to compete with major AI companies. Canada does not have the resources nor the wherewithal to engage in a frontier race with the world’s two superpowers, but the federal government has identified a path to limiting its dependence on China and the United States.
Mapping the Davos Philosophy Onto Artificial Intelligence
Mr. Carney has so far shown himself as a pragmatic realist who will take the world as it is, not how he wishes it to be. Since the Prime Minister originally expressed his core tenets during his speech at Davos in 2025, Mr. Carney’s maxim has remained consistent. Following the Davos philosophy is the exact approach that a uniquely vulnerable middle power, like Canada, ought to employ during the AI era.
Mr. Carney cannot become the transformative leader of the middle powers that he seeks to be without taking a meaningful stance on the direction of artificial intelligence. In contrast to the hard power approach of the US, Canada retains credibility as an international broker. The release of the AI for All strategy in June was a promising, though unremarkable, start for Canada’s future as a global leader in this sector. However, there is more work to be done. Canada can further leverage its position of global leadership to earn a seat on standards bodies, offer its clean power supply to reduce computing emissions, and bridge between different coalitions to ensure a consistent global plan on AI that keeps the tech sector from consolidating even more power and wealth. Canada will never be able to compete directly with the global tech superpowers, but increased investment and innovation will aid the country in maintaining its data sovereignty. It appears that AI is the future; Canada must seek to control its own destiny if it is to navigate the long road ahead.
Edited by Willa Merer
The argument defended in this article is solely that of the author and does not reflect the position of the McGill Journal of Political Science, the Political Science Students’ Association, or the McGill Department of Political Science.
Featured Image by BalticServers obtained via Wikimedia Commons
