The Right to Vote: Comparing Overseas Voting Rights in Israel and Canada

Voting Rights in Israel 

In Israel, voting from abroad is out of reach for almost all citizens residing overseas. Under Israeli electoral law, there is no general mail-in voting for regular citizens. Unless an Israeli is working abroad as an official diplomat, they must be physically present in the country on election day to vote. This requirement creates a major issue for the estimated 600,000 to 800,000 Israeli citizens living abroad. The effects of this policy have become increasingly apparent ahead of Israel’s 2026 parliamentary elections. This is particularly significant in Israel, where election outcomes shape decisions on national security, the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, and the country’s overall future direction. 

This regulation also raises concerns regarding voter suppression. Before the elections, reports had surfaced that senior transportation officials were considering measures to limit incoming flights right before election day to prevent citizens from returning to Israel to vote. In response, the Association for Civil Rights in Israel (ACRI) filed an urgent legal petition with the Central Elections Committee, the attorney general and the Minister of Transportation. ACRI Attorney Elza Bugnet argues that because Israeli law provides no mail-in options, attempting to restrict flights home is an unconstitutional violation of fundamental democratic rights and the right to enter the country. The ACRI emphasized that using state authority to restrict travel out of fear that overseas voters might vote against the incumbent government represents an illegal misuse of power. Concurrently, Israel’s requirement of physical presence in voting creates a clear geographic inequality in access to voting. While an Israeli citizen living in Toronto or New York must pay for a flight to participate in national elections, over 750,000 Israelis living in the West Bank settlements can vote easily at local polling stations set up directly in their communities. This creates a gap between citizens whose geographic location makes voting accessible and those for whom participation comes with significant financial and logistical barriers. The distinction is important because, although both groups hold the same Israeli citizenship and formal voting rights, their ability to participate in national elections is defined by where they live. 

Canada’s Ultimate Voter Ruling

Canada takes a dramatically different approach from Israel, though its current system was shaped by years of legal debate about the legitimacy of voting abroad. The Canada Elections Act had a strict rule: any Canadian citizen who lived outside the country for more than five consecutive years lost their right to vote in federal elections. The government defended this five-year limit using traditional social contract claims, arguing that voting rights should belong primarily to resident citizens who pay local taxes, participate in daily civic life, and live directly under the laws passed by Parliament.

This policy was overturned in the 2019 Supreme Court of Canada ruling, Frank V. Canada. Plaintiffs Gillian Frank and Jaime Duonog challenged the five-year restriction as a violation of Section 3 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, which guarantees every Canadian citizen the right to vote. This led to the Supreme Court ruling in favour and striking down the restriction. On behalf of the majority, Chief Justice Richard Wagner argued that the government had “failed to produce evidence showing that non-resident voters harm electoral integrity.” The Courts established that a citizenship does not simply disappear because one lives outside of Canada. Today, Canada guarantees universal absentee voting for all eligible citizens abroad. By simply registering with the International Register of Electors through Elections Canada, citizens who are living, studying and working anywhere in the world can receive a mail-in ballot package. 

A Voice beyond borders

Policies regarding overseas voting decide which citizens get a voice in a country’s political future. In highly competitive elections where parliamentary minorities and majorities can hinge on a small number of seats, disregarding thousands of citizens living abroad can significantly alter election results. In Israel, where expats make up 10% of the electorate, introducing remote voting would change the balance of power in the Israeli parliament. This is particularly significant given that many Israelis living abroad oppose former Prime Minister Netanyahu’s right-winged policies and his government’s actions in Gaza, and their participation could influence the war in Gaza and the broader conflicts in the Middle East.

Moreover, requiring citizens to fly home makes voting a financial privilege —accessible only to those who can afford a plane ticket. The divergent electoral systems between Israel and Canada raise considerations about what citizenship means in a globalized world, as millions of people live and study across international borders while still being impacted by their home countries’ laws and international policies. A comparison of Israel and Canada’s overseas voting laws begs the question about modern democracy: should citizens’ political participation be constrained within state borders, or should their electoral rights follow them extraterritorially?

Edited by Laila Graham

The argument defended in this article is solely that of the author and does not reflect the position of the McGill Journal of Political Science, the Political Science Students’ Association, or the McGill Department of Political Science. 

Featured Image by: Noam Galai on Getty Images